Press "Enter" to skip to content

How Medicare for all is tripping up Democrats



Shortly after announcing her presidential campaign in January, Sen. Kamala Harris said she’d get rid of private insurance as part of her plan to enact a “Medicare for all” single-payer health care system. That didn’t go over so well with the 177 million Americans who have private coverage and would lose it. So Harris backtracked from that and promoted a Medicare for all plan that would include private insurers. Confusion ensued.

Harris dropped her presidential bid on Dec. 3, as she sank in the polls and funding dried up. Her shifts on health care didn’t single-handedly sink her campaign. But it mystified voters and typified the difficulty Democratic candidates are having pushing for health care reforms that are both transformative and doable.

With Harris gone, the main Democratic candidates who support Medicare for all are Bernie Sanders—who wrote the damn bill—and Elizabeth Warren. Sanders’ socialist preferences are well known, and his support among Democrats has consistently run around 20% for most of the current campaign. Warren is newer to voters, and she’s been developing fresh policy proposals for the last several months. And like Harris, Warren has vacillated on health care as voters seem to disapprove.

Warren hit a high point in October, when a Quinnipiac poll showed her in first place nationally, with 28% of Democratic voters saying Warren was their first choice for president. Joe Biden was second, with 21%.

At the same time, however, Biden and many others were pressing Warren to explain how she’d pay for Medicare for all, which would probably require a doubling of federal outlays each year and sharp tax hikes to finance it. Sanders has suggested he’d pay for the giant plan with a 4% income-tax surcharge on families making more than $29,000. Families would still end up better off, he says, since they’d pay nothing for health care.

Warren won’t commit to a middle-class tax hike because she knows her opponents would pound her for it if she did. So in early November she released a plan to finance Medicare for all with a wealth tax on millionaires, new business taxes, reduced military spending and better efficiencies. The middle class would get something—free health care—for nothing, as long as her lowball cost estimate for Medicare for all and highball revenue estimate for new taxes panned out.
In case they don’t, Warren now has a backup plan. In mid-November, Warren released a “transition” plan that would come before Medicare for all. This would be a new public health plan for people who need it that leaves private insurance in place. It’s very much like the “public option” plans Pete Buttigieg and Joe Biden support. Both of those campaigns trashed Warren for flip-flopping and trying to kill private insurance in the first place.

‘A vote loser’
Look what happened next: Warren tanked in the polls, falling to 14% in November in the same Quinnipiac poll that showed her to be the front-runner in October. Part of that drop might have been the surprising rise of 37-year-old Pete Buttigieg. But part of it is also probably voters souring on Medicare for all as they learn of the new taxes it would require and the likely disruption it would cause.

Support for Medicare for all among all voters has fallen from 51% in 2017 to 36% now, according to Quinnipiac. A survey of swing-state voters by the Kaiser Family Foundation and Cook Political Report found that 62% say Medicare for all is a bad idea, while just 36% say it’s a good idea. Alan Abramowitz of the University of Virginia’s Center for Politics studied voting patterns in the 2018 midterms and determined that Medicare for all is a “vote loser.”

What’s much clearer now than when Kamala Harris first said she’d get rid of private insurance is that Medicare for all appeals to many Democrats but drives away many swing voters who will be essential to winning the presidency in 2020. Warren, like Harris before her, is trying to appeal to both groups. But that comes with a tradeoff: some voters in both groups turn on a candidate who will seemingly say anything to get elected instead of standing up for a gut belief.

Bernie Sanders is the guy who sticks to his principles. But he tried this once, in 2016, and his views are probably still too extreme to win the Democratic nomination. And some Democratic voters who might like Sanders don’t think he can beat Trump, so they’ll end up casting ballots for somebody else. Cornering the fringe vote is no way to win.

Subscribe to Yahoo Finance: https://yhoo.it/2fGu5Bb

Connect with Yahoo Finance:
Get the latest news: https://yhoo.it/2fGu5Bb
Find Yahoo Finance on Facebook: http://bit.ly/2A9u5Zq
Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter: http://bit.ly/2LMgloP
Follow Yahoo Finance on Instagram: http://bit.ly/2LOpNYz

11
Leave a Reply

avatar
11 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
0 Comment authors
1EstebandDakota BryantJoeLovesHistoryKrugzugNick Molon Labe Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Shawn
Guest
Shawn

I will go to the ends of the earth for Bernie. I will organize and defend universal healthcare till I die.

Nun Ya
Guest
Nun Ya

Insurance companies make lots and lots of money.
The model they use to profit is to completely screw the "little guy".

Peter Thomas
Guest
Peter Thomas

These people act like voters don’t want medicare for all, completely false

Dakota Bryant
Guest
Dakota Bryant

I still don't get why they argue about private insurance. Nobody loves their healthcare providers, in fact many hate them. Nobody cares that they're losing their private insurance except for the wealthy who have very high quality healthcare.

Dakota Bryant
Guest
Dakota Bryant

Bernie is the second most popular candidate, he's also the most popular in California. "nobody thinks he has a chance to win the primary" Lol

JoeLovesHistory
Guest
JoeLovesHistory

BERNIE SANDERS IS WINNING IN CALIFORNIA AND NEW HAMPSHIRE THIS NARRATIVE IS MISLEADING. BERNIE IS FOR SINGLE PAYER MEDICARE FOR ALL WITH NON-DUPLICATIVE COVERAGE CLAUSE AND HE KEEPS RISING IN THE POLLS!!!

Krugzug
Guest
Krugzug

A nice neo-liberal take on Medicare for all. Bernie Sanders polling is still high because he is not wavering on his position, while all the others have. What does it feel like to be a sell-out to your own viewers?

Nick Molon Labe
Guest
Nick Molon Labe

Democrats giving out free stuff paid for by US tax payer. I will vote for Biden if he will give free poly grip for us seniors.

Wally Wally
Guest
Wally Wally

The only question to ask repeatedly to PELOSI do you hate the PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES and asked repeatedly, repeatedly and repeatedly.

Ronald McDonald
Guest
Ronald McDonald

Will aggregate individual tax bill = about 70% of total income?

1Esteband
Guest
1Esteband

There is so much fraud with Medicare that US cost of healthcare is 2X more per capita than other developed countries, and our life expectancy is worst than them.
We need to make a system based on the german health care.